buildings energy efficiency

All_posts

Air-to-Air Heat Pump Heating: Split, VRF and VRV Systems in Practice

Air to air heat pump heating with split and VRF/VRV systems
Outdoor units of a VRF air-to-air heat pump system on a flat roof
Outdoor units of a VRF system on a flat roof

🔥 Air to air heat pump heating: a real alternative, not a gadget

You can theorise endlessly about so-called “refrigerant” heating and cooling systems, but I will speak from a practical point of view, as a former sceptic, and try to make the case for a few of their advantages. For a long time I was sceptical about air-to-air heat pumps. After gaining experience with modern, good-quality equipment and running the analyses, I was won over: today’s refrigerant heating and cooling systems are a serious heat source.

I am an enthusiast of energy efficiency, but I am not detached from reality. Day to day I work on retrofits, advise on investments and, above all, operate the HVAC installations of many very different buildings.

Key takeaways: split and VRF/VRV units can be the main heat source; VRF with heat recovery heats and cools different rooms at the same time; good units are rated to heat down to −15 to −25 °C; in a big city temperatures below −13 °C are rare; down to about −5 °C VRF heating was cheaper than district heating; if a unit cools fine but heats poorly, check the refrigerant charge

For most people, heating with split or VRF/VRV air-conditioning units running in heating mode (as a heat pump) still looks more like a feeble supplementary gadget than a serious way to heat a building in the Polish climate. That is partly true, but largely out of date. The technology of so-called air-source heat pumps has developed so quickly that we can now treat “refrigerant” heating and cooling systems as an attractive alternative to conventional hydronic heating and cooling.

Split and VRF systems are simply highly efficient, advanced heating and cooling heat pumps: air-to-air and (optionally, for some designs) air-to-water.

🏗️ Where they come in handy: retrofits and extensions

Retrofits and extensions of ventilation, cooling and heating can be awkward when it comes to delivering heat and cold: you interfere with existing installations, have to route new pipework, rebalance the system and so on. You also have to allow for heating and cooling capacity reserves, which, because of a slightly changing climate and high comfort expectations, are often right at the limit.

When rebuilding or extending a building, or upgrading floor areas or air handling units, I usually go for refrigerant heating and cooling systems, even as the main source of heat and cooling. It is much easier and faster, and often even cheaper. Extending or altering the chilled-water and process-heat installation for part of a building can be more troublesome, and even more expensive, than fitting air-to-air heating and cooling heat pumps. On top of that, we gain higher energy efficiency compared with the existing installations.

❄️ Split, multi-split and VRF/VRV: what is the difference?

Split and multi-split units are simple, cheap and familiar air conditioners; a multi-split system lets you connect several indoor units to one outdoor unit. The trade-off is limited functionality, capacity and pipework length.

VRF (Variable Refrigerant Flow; VRV, Variable Refrigerant Volume, is Daikin’s name for the same idea) is a system that can be adapted widely in capacity, number of indoor units and pipework length. Current VRF systems offer their users the highest standards of comfort, reinforced by high reliability.

A VRF system is technologically advanced, so it needs competent specialists to design and install the refrigerant circuit. But if you add good-quality equipment, you get an exceptionally reliable system, even compared with traditional heating and cooling based on water-fed fan coil units and a full chilled-water and process-heat installation.

Advantages of VRF

  • High reliability.
  • Quick and simple installation.
  • Thin, flexible pipework that is quick to install.
  • The low weight and small size of the outdoor unit allow it to be placed on the roof slabs of even existing buildings.
  • Large systems are possible (total pipework length up to 1,000 m).
  • Efficient heat recovery when different areas are heated and cooled at the same time. Heat taken from cooled rooms can be used to heat other rooms or to warm domestic hot water.
  • High energy efficiency, especially in the heat recovery variant.
  • Individual temperature control in each zone. Some manufacturers also offer heated or chilled water for rooms where refrigerant cannot be used directly.
  • Full integration with building management systems (BMS).

Reliability. VRF systems are widely regarded as the most advanced air-conditioning solutions on the market. Their technical sophistication would suggest poor reliability, which, oddly enough, reality does not confirm. Personally, I back proven manufacturers such as Fujitsu and Mitsubishi, which have shown exceptional reliability over many years of operation.

♻️ Simultaneous heating and cooling: heat recovery

In office and commercial buildings we often get large local heat gains, so even in winter some rooms need cooling. As we know well, users are very demanding about comfort, so I advise considering VRF systems that can heat and cool different rooms at the same time. In practice such a system is also even more economical, because it recovers heat from the cooled areas.

Good practical advice. VRF systems come in two main variants as far as heating and cooling go. The first is cheaper by around 10–15%: all indoor units work either in heating or in cooling mode, so you cannot heat and cool different rooms at the same time. The second variant is a 3-pipe system (2-pipe for Mitsubishi) with heat recovery, which lets you choose heating or cooling mode freely at any moment.

For example, you can cool a conference room full of people in the core of the building while heating the CEO’s office on an outer wall. On top of that, the heat taken from the conference room is used to warm the CEO’s office. This is a real-life example, so in many conditions the saving on the slightly cheaper system would come back to bite you in the form of well-deserved user complaints.

Diagram of a heat recovery VRF system: the outdoor unit feeds three refrigerant pipes (two in Mitsubishi Electric's version) to a branch box, which sets the conference room in the building core to cooling and the CEO's office on the external wall to heating; heat removed from the conference room is moved to the office, and the outdoor unit only covers the difference. A heat-pump-only VRF is about 10–15% cheaper, but all its indoor units must heat or all must cool.
Heat recovery VRF: the conference room is cooled, the CEO’s office is heated, and the heat moves between them through the refrigerant

From observing many office and commercial buildings, simultaneous heating and cooling of different rooms (with different heat gains and losses) is the norm, even at sub-zero outdoor temperatures. In such conditions, thanks to heat recovery, even a slightly more expensive system pays for itself in saved energy. In addition, if the heat pump is the only heat source, you need to select suitable dedicated units, ideally able to heat at outdoor temperatures of at least −20 °C.

I have described simultaneous heating and cooling many times, for example in marnotrawstwo-energii-w-praktyce (an article in Polish about wasted energy in practice). A VRF system with heat recovery, skilfully laid out, is in itself a nearly ideal management system for “heat and cold” energy. The same logic, using heat you already have instead of throwing it away, is behind heating buildings with distributed data centres.

A VRF system with heat recovery fits the role of local cooling and heating of rooms in office and commercial settings extremely well.

🌡️ How do air-source heat pumps actually perform in frost?

There is a common belief that air-to-air heat pumps cannot heat effectively in severe frost (below −5 °C or −10 °C). That is true, but only of old, low-quality units. Today manufacturers typically guarantee heating from −15 °C to −20 °C, and even −25 °C. Of course, energy efficiency and heating capacity drop at extremely low temperatures.

But who actually records such hard frosts in large cities? Winter temperatures in a city are several degrees higher than outside it, and extremely low temperatures are very rare. This is the urban heat island effect: buildings and roads absorb heat and release it slowly, especially at night (see the US EPA’s explanation of heat islands).

Take a building near the centre of Warsaw, equipped with a Siemens energy management system that monitors outdoor temperatures, heat substation parameters and so on. According to the Siemens reports, outdoor temperatures below about −13 °C are isolated, short-lived events over the course of a year, and temperatures below −20 °C have not been recorded so far.

Outdoor temperature scale from +5 °C to −30 °C: down to about −5 °C VRF heating cost less than district heating and air handling unit refrigerant coils are set to work down to −5 °C; old, cheap units used to give up between −5 and −10 °C; in central Warsaw temperatures below −13 °C occur only in short spells; heat pump modules in air handling units cover 100% of the heat demand down to −15 °C; −20 °C has never been recorded at the building; good units today are rated to heat between −15 and −25 °C; as the only heat source choose units that heat at −20 °C or lower
How cold it really gets in the city, and what a good heat pump can handle (figures from the buildings described in this article)

A curiosity: if an air conditioner cools properly but struggles to heat, even when it is not below zero outside, this usually points to a shortage of refrigerant. The shortage does not necessarily come from a leak; it may simply be that the charge was not topped up to suit the pipework length during installation.

Frost does not kill heat pumps, bad installation does: three identical units on one wall, only the bottom one in ice (video, 6 min)

✅ Examples of effective heating with heat pumps

  • My own office. Like the whole small building, it is heated and cooled by an air-to-air multi-split system plus optional electric heaters. It is a difficult case: most of it consists of external walls or borders unheated rooms, and the ventilation is hybrid, without heat recovery. Throughout the winter of 2016/2017 we heated the office with the multi-split air conditioners alone, and we did not record a single case of the heat pump lacking heating capacity.
  • Several hundred split and multi-split units. That is how many I operate. Some users successfully use them for supplementary heating of rooms.
  • Air handling units. Colleagues at the service department of a well-known Swedish manufacturer tell me that their heating and cooling modules for air handling units comfortably cover 100% of the unit’s heat demand down to −15 °C. Below −15 °C they are supported by an electric heater, which, in big-city Polish conditions, is needed extremely rarely, as the service engineers themselves confirm.
  • A whole building during commissioning. The heat substation had problems, and for almost the whole winter the building was heated effectively by a heat pump: a VRF system originally intended mainly for cooling.
  • Refurbished air handling units. Many of the units we add during refurbishments and extensions have a refrigerant cooling coil that can also heat the air. The heat pump usually works well as the primary heat source, possibly backed up by electric heaters, which makes it possible to drop traditional water-based heating and cooling altogether. In some cases we combine a refrigerant module with a traditional heating coil; there the refrigerant coil takes over air heating, and we usually configure it to work in the energy-efficient range of outdoor temperatures down to −5 °C.
  • A drugstore chain. Many stores and refurbishments of one of the largest drugstore chains rely 100% on air-to-air heat pump (air conditioning) systems for both heating and cooling.

💷 Running and installation costs

If you consider refrigerant systems purely as a heat source and compare them with conventional heating systems, the costs are usually higher, although not necessarily for retrofits and small projects. But if you look at a refrigerant system that both heats and cools, and take into account the many advantages over traditional solutions, then in many cases it will be the better option.

Given my energy prices and the efficiency of our VRF and other refrigerant heating and cooling units, we estimated that down to an outdoor temperature of about −5 °C, heating with an air-conditioning system is even more energy-efficient than district heating. For the more initiated: we took the defrosting of outdoor units into account, which is switched on significantly less often below 0 °C because the air is drier. Of course, it all depends on the quality of the heat pumps and on electricity and heat prices in each case.

Frost builds up fastest around 0 °C, when the air is cold but still holds plenty of water; in a dry, hard frost the outdoor unit needs defrosting less often

🔄 What has changed since this was written (2026 update)

I wrote this article in 2017. The physics has not changed; the refrigerants have. Under the new EU F-gas Regulation (EU) 2024/573, the amount of HFC refrigerants allowed on the EU market keeps shrinking until HFCs are phased out completely in 2050, and their scarcity already makes them expensive. R410A, the standard refrigerant in VRF systems of that era, is giving way to R32, with roughly a third of its global warming potential, and in smaller units to natural refrigerants such as propane (R290).

In practice: if you are choosing a VRF system today, ask what refrigerant it uses and what servicing and top-ups will cost in ten years, not only about the price and the COP. If you operate an older R410A system, keep it leak-tight, because every kilogram you have to add will cost more each year.

📌 In summary

Above all, I wanted to share my practical experience and observations of the many practical advantages of refrigerant heating and cooling systems. The article also aims to show that a heat pump can be taken seriously as a heat source. As practice shows, properly selected heating and cooling units have many advantages and in many cases are a very favourable solution.

Many people, including designers, are still not convinced by heat pumps. Often this resistance comes from fear and/or laziness about trying something new, or from established arrangements with suppliers. It is one of the classic myths of energy efficiency.

❓ FAQ: air to air heat pump heating

Can an air-to-air heat pump be the only heat source in a building?

Yes, if you select dedicated units that can heat at outdoor temperatures of at least −20 °C. In the examples above, a whole building ran on its VRF heat pump for almost an entire winter, and many stores of a large drugstore chain rely on air-to-air heat pumps alone for both heating and cooling.

What is the difference between VRF and VRV?

None in principle. VRF (Variable Refrigerant Flow) is the generic term; VRV (Variable Refrigerant Volume) is Daikin’s name for the same type of system.

Is a heat recovery VRF worth the extra cost?

In offices and shops, usually yes. It costs around 10–15% more, but it can cool one room and heat another at the same time, moving heat between them instead of wasting it, and users stop complaining that the system is in the “wrong” mode.

Why does my air conditioner cool well but heat poorly?

Most often because of a shortage of refrigerant. It does not have to be a leak: the charge may never have been topped up to suit the pipework length during installation.

Leave a Reply