buildings energy efficiency

All_posts

Evaporative Air Cooler: Does It Really Cool? Not Much

Evaporative air cooler, a humidifier sold as a cooler

Does a humidifier sold as an evaporative air cooler (in Poland, a so-called “klimatyzer”) actually cool the air? Yes, but only weakly. It cools by evaporating water, which is really just a side effect of an evaporative or ultrasonic humidifier. So although the air does get cooler, you are using a humidifier: it raises the humidity, which is very unfavourable in poorly ventilated rooms. In my test the cooling was about 3–4 °C in a closed room, paid for with higher humidity, and the whole device is nothing like a proper air conditioner with an outdoor unit. Why is it not worth buying? Let’s start with how it works and why it works so poorly:

Evaporative air cooler – does it cool or just humidify?: In practice it is an evaporative or ultrasonic humidifier; It cools by evaporating water, much like sweating; Cooling power is negligible compared with a split air conditioner; It raises the humidity in the room; In poorly ventilated rooms it increases the risk of moisture problems; Real cooling needs an air conditioner with an outdoor unit
Thermal camera image of the cooled air at the outlet of an evaporative air cooler: about 21 °C on a 20–28 °C scale
Thermal camera image of the cooled air at the humidifier outlet (21 °C on a 20–28 °C scale). It is cooler than the room, but the cooling capacity is negligible

💧 How an evaporative air cooler works

Evaporative air coolers and ultrasonic humidifiers either spray a water mist into the air or, like evaporative humidifiers, increase the evaporation surface on special drums and the like. When water evaporates (evaporation, an adiabatic process), it draws energy from its surroundings, which produces a cooling effect (only a fraction of what split and multi-split air conditioners offer). The human thermoregulation system works in a similar way. We simply sweat when it is too hot, and that is how the body gets rid of excess heat. It is worth remembering that we experience high temperatures differently when the air is dry and when it is humid. High humidity (air saturated with water vapour) limits evaporation – and with it our own thermoregulation, as well as the performance of the air cooler itself.

Diagram: how an evaporative air cooler works – an evaporative humidifier with a wet drum and fan, and an ultrasonic humidifier with a transducer that breaks water into mist; evaporation slightly lowers the temperature and raises the humidity
How an evaporative air cooler cools: evaporative and ultrasonic humidifiers – evaporation takes heat out of the air, but the energy stays in the room as water vapour
Video of the experiment

So by raising humidity with a humidifier (an evaporative air cooler) in closed rooms, we reduce our ability to thermoregulate. As a result, we also make the air feel stuffier and the heat harder to bear.

Xiaomi Evaporative Humidifier – the drum that increases the evaporation surface and the auxiliary fan are visible
Xiaomi evaporative humidifier – you can see the drum that increases the evaporation surface and the fan. Sold as an “air cooler”, it is still a humidifier

🌬️ Evaporative cooling and natural ventilation

Note that natural (stack) ventilation practically does not work in hot weather. So running an evaporative air cooler (or a humidifier used as one) with the windows closed makes the room stuffy (rising CO2) and raises the humidity, which makes comfort worse. An evaporative air cooler only makes sense in well-ventilated rooms.

Measurements next to an evaporative air cooler: a handheld meter for temperature, humidity and CO2 in front of the outlet, and an air quality monitor showing the room readings
Measurements in a closed room: the air cooled by only about 3–4 °C, at the cost of higher humidity (and CO2 without ventilation)

⚖️ Is an evaporative air cooler worth buying? My opinion:

Generally, an evaporative air cooler has only one thing in common with a split or portable air conditioner: it cools the air. It just does so far, far less effectively. So an evaporative air cooler can only be considered in special cases, or when a normal split / multi-split, VRF or VRV air conditioning system simply cannot be installed. Air conditioning lowers humidity (by condensation on the cooling coil) instead of raising it, as evaporative coolers do. On top of that, air conditioning usually has an incomparably higher cooling capacity. So is an evaporative air cooler worth buying? In most cases you are better off buying a fan if you cannot or do not want to install real air conditioning…

Comparison: an evaporative air cooler raises humidity and leaves the heat in the room, while a split air conditioner dries the air and rejects the heat through the outdoor unit
Evaporative air cooler vs split air conditioner: temperature, humidity and where the heat goes

Of course, this article is about domestic use. In general, adiabatic cooling (the evaporation process) is one of the most energy-efficient ways of cooling and is widely used in professional systems. But using this kind of cooling directly in closed, poorly ventilated rooms is asking for trouble.

🔗 See also

💧 The air purifier with humidifier I recommend

Philips PureProtect Water 3400 – purifies and humidifies in one. Usually cheapest on Amazon, especially just before and at the start of the season: Amazon. Review: Philips PureProtect Water 3400 air purifier with humidifier.

The Amazon link is an affiliate link: if you buy through it, I get a small commission, and the price for you does not change.

Leave a Reply