buildings energy efficiency

All_posts

Best Humidifier for Home: A Practical Guide from an Engineer

Best humidifier for home: an engineer practical guide

Air that is too dry, especially below 30% relative humidity, is very bad for your health (irritated mucous membranes and a higher susceptibility to infections). It is best to keep humidity between 40% and 60%. Remember, too much is not good either. First lower the temperature in your home – that already raises the humidity – but it will not replace a humidifier. The best humidifier for home use is an evaporative one, ideally a mechanical one, usually a drum rotating in water or similar. Alternatively, on a budget, a radiator-mounted humidifier with an evaporative pad is quite good, because those ceramic little water containers are mostly just decoration. A steam humidifier is healthy and effective, but it uses a great deal of electricity. It is better to avoid ultrasonic humidifiers, because they can only be used safely with demineralised or distilled water. On ordinary tap water they generate dangerous PM2.5 dust, because all the minerals in the water get sprayed into the air! More information below:

Which humidifier for home?: keep humidity at 40–60%, below 30% harms your health; first lower the temperature – relative humidity will rise; best choice: a mechanical evaporative humidifier with a drum; cheapest sensible option: a radiator humidifier with a pad; steam is healthy and effective but uses a lot of energy; ultrasonic only with distilled water – tap water produces PM2.5
Best humidifier for home: a practical guide from an engineer
Best humidifier for home: a practical guide from an engineer

Hi! For many years I have worked in the operation and optimisation of buildings, with a strong focus on the comfort of some of the largest buildings in Poland and, more recently, around the world. Drawing on that experience, I will try to explain in simple terms how humidity and air humidification work in our homes, and give some advice on which humidifier to choose. First, a quick introduction to what air humidity is and why it matters so much, and then an overview of the humidification methods available at home. I have tested every type of home humidification for you, and I am also sharing what I have learned from humidifying the air in office buildings, medical facilities and the like.

🔍 Understanding the humidification problem:

What is relative humidity (RH)? Relative? Yes – relative to temperature! The humidity of the very same air, with exactly the same amount of water vapour dissolved in it like sugar in water, changes with temperature! We measure humidity in %, which tells us how saturated the air is with water vapour at a given temperature. A question to ponder: does sugar dissolve better in warm or in cold water? Air absorbing moisture works in a similar way.

Here is an example from our own homes of how the humidity of the same air, holding the same amount of water, behaves around a hairdryer and around a cold beer or other cold drink:

  1. 🌡️ Before drying: the air is at 21°C and 45% humidity – ideal conditions
  2. 💇 Drying: after the hairdryer heats the air to 40°C, the very same air has a humidity of 16% and becomes so dry that it intensively absorbs moisture from its surroundings – that is, from our hair.
  3. When you take a cold beer or cola out of the fridge, dew starts to condense out of the air, because next to the surface of a cold drink the humidity of the same air reaches 100% already at 8°C – that is, the dew point. So the very same air that was in the hairdryer will start to drop water in the form of dew.

So the relative humidity of freezing winter air can be 100%, which is often confusing, because once that same air is heated to room temperature, it sometimes has less than 20% humidity, which is harmful.

I recommend watching an experiment that shows how relative humidity behaves

A humidity calculator for 2 different sets of conditions is available at otech.pl

🏜️ Air that is too dry – the risks

The most comfortable humidity for people is around 40–60%, but in winter I would recommend no more than 50%, because of the risk of water condensing on cold window parts and on corner walls (a higher risk of mould).

Interior of a heated home in winter, a hot radiator under the window, a hygrometer with its needle in the red zone below 30%; in the background a person

Low humidity dries out the skin and irritates the conjunctiva and mucous membranes, causing a feeling of dryness in the throat and nose. As a result of the irritated mucous membranes, resistance to infections drops and the immune system works less well. Mucous membranes dry out excessively when humidity falls below 40%. In practice, all these complaints get worse below 30%. Humidity above 60%, and especially above 70%, causes a feeling of stuffiness and limits the body’s ability to regulate temperature (sweating), which is particularly unpleasant in summer.

🧣 Which humidifier is the cheapest and healthiest? Put on warm winter clothes and lower the temperature, and the relative humidity will rise!

This paragraph is available as a video;)

A person in a thick woollen jumper turning a radiator thermostatic head to a lower setting; next to it a hygrometer with its needle

Simply lower the temperature in your home to 19–21°C and dress warmer, as befits the winter season, and you will partly raise the humidity while cutting your energy use and boosting your vitality. Of course, that will not be enough on the driest days, but it will significantly improve conditions compared with an overheated room. As an example, lowering the temperature in an overheated room from 25°C to a healthy 20°C raises the humidity by about 10%!!! (The relationship is not linear, hence the example calculations, and that is why I gave the link to the calculator earlier.)

Comparison of air humidity at different temperatures
Example calculations of how lowering the temperature in your home affects the increase in humidity

People tend towards laziness and comfort-seeking, which in excess often takes its toll on health. Thanks to cheap and widespread access to heating, we significantly overheat our rooms. It is a similar analogy to the availability of high-calorie food.

I have seen people heat rooms to 25–26°C in winter and walk around in summer clothes with the windows and ventilation openings tightly shut. In such rooms you could hang an axe in the air (as the Polish saying goes). Yet those same people often complain about a nagging runny nose, coughing and the like. A coincidence?

Personally, I have a newborn at home, and the recommended temperature after leaving hospital was 21 to 23°C. After a week and a half, the paediatrician and the midwife advised keeping it at 19–21°C. What is it like in practice? People typically keep their homes at 23–26°C in winter, and at 20–21°C they can already start reporting heating problems (my experience from dozens of office and residential buildings)! These same people often torment themselves with diets and exercise while undermining their health by overheating their rooms. Put on warm clothes, let in more fresh air and live healthier.

The cheapest and healthiest way to humidify air in winter? Put on warm winter clothes and lower the temperature, and the relative humidity will rise!
The cheapest and healthiest way to humidify air in winter? Put on warm winter clothes and lower the temperature, and the relative humidity will rise!

⚠️ Ultrasonic humidifiers – drawbacks and downsides. Yes, you read that right.

Ultrasonic humidifiers generate a so-called cold mist by breaking water into droplets on a membrane. Ultrasonic humidifiers are the most popular because they humidify fairly efficiently and are reasonably priced. However, they have one huge drawback! They can only run on chemically pure water, that is, demineralised or distilled water. Water from filter jugs or straight from the tap is not suitable. So whatever you save by buying an ultrasonic humidifier will be eaten up by buying demineralised water, not to mention having to carry it home from the shop…

Why is chemically pure water needed in an ultrasonic humidifier? Because when the mist is generated, all the minerals dissolved in the water are broken up on the membrane and released into the air, producing very harmful particulate matter, including PM2.5 particles that pass through cell membranes! Personally, I advise against using such humidifiers.

I recommend this University of Alberta article on air pollution caused by ultrasonic humidifiers: ualberta.ca
In my own measurements, ultrasonic humidifiers generated up to about 255 micrograms per m³ of PM2.5 in a room!!!! I tested some no-name humidifiers, but as the article I linked shows, it is a real health hazard. Friends have also told me that when they switched on branded ultrasonic humidifiers, their air purifiers with pollution sensors went haywire.

♨️ Steam humidifiers

They produce steam by boiling water and in this way raise the humidity – a bit like a kettle. It is a hygienic solution, but the most expensive, because of its very high electricity consumption, and these units also often need descaling. Because of the cost of electricity I advise against this solution, unless hygiene requirements demand absolute sterility, which in excess is not beneficial either. NOTE: it can be confusing that ultrasonic humidifiers are often described as steam humidifiers!!! True steam humidifiers work by boiling water, not by creating so-called cold mist, which can be unhealthy as described above.

What water does a steam humidifier need? Any will do, because the evaporation (boiling) process does not release minerals – they stay on the heating elements. So, to limit limescale on the heating elements, it is best to use filtered water (from a filter jug, a water treatment station and so on); demineralised or distilled water would also work, but it is a waste of money;).

🏆 Best humidifier for home? Mechanical evaporative humidifiers – the Optimiser’s favourite

In principle, this is a very simple way of humidifying by letting water evaporate naturally. They often come as standalone devices, such as the Xiaomi Evaporative Humidifier, or combined with air purifiers, such as the SHARP UA-HD40E-L Plasmacluster:

Conceptual cross-section (no labels): a porous drum partly submerged in a bowl of water, rotating and lifting moisture; beside it
  1. Mechanical, where a rotating drum, partly submerged, “grinds up” the water, increasing the evaporation area to the whole surface of the drum. The drum is porous and has many chambers or discs, to increase the evaporation surface. It is as if you hung your laundry out to dry on a clothes rack… There is usually an additional fan to speed up the humidification.

Advantages:

+ fairly high humidification output regardless of conditions

+ healthy humidification, provided it is serviced regularly – change the water and wash it about every 3–4 days – here is the servicing of an example humidifier like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0LAYU5jc0k

+ you can use ordinary tap water in an evaporative humidifier, which makes them cheap to run

+ low energy consumption – only enough to turn the drum and, possibly, run the fan

+ they partly clean the air, as impurities collect in the water and on the drum – please see the servicing videos

+ the humidifier can be automated and remotely controlled, as with the Xiaomi Evaporative Humidifier

Disadvantages:

– fairly frequent cleaning, every 3–4 days, to prevent the water going stale and so on. It is hard to call this a drawback, but it needs more attention than other humidifiers. All in all, you could even count it as an advantage, because the water in the humidifier collects pollutants from the air.

– paradoxically, these are among the most expensive humidifiers to buy, but all in all they are healthy and very efficient

– minimal noise at the lowest speed, but at higher speeds it can be annoying. Personally, mine runs constantly on the 1st, quiet speed

⭐ My review of the SmartMi Evaporative Humidifier:

I sincerely recommend this humidifier. It provides healthy humidification, unlike ultrasonic ones, and it is effective – it is enough for a 43 m² flat, it is reasonably quiet (it could be a touch quieter on speeds 2 and 3) and it has convenient app control.
It is worth noting that this 43 m² is intensively ventilated, so the humidifier has more work to do. On very dry days:
On speed 1 it is quiet (a minimal murmur) and gives about 37–40%.
On speed 2 it comfortably pushes past 40% and manages 40–50%*, depending on conditions. There is always speed 3;)
Sometimes I notice a slight overestimate of humidity compared with other measurements, but that is only about 2% RH. To automate the humidifier (the app is brilliant: xiaomi), I use the readings from my Smartmi Air Purifier 3H (I recommend paying extra over the 3C version to get decent temperature and humidity measurement).
The downsides: on speed 2 it may be audible and on speed 3 a bit loud, but I am oversensitive about noise. However, when the humidifier runs in another room I do not hear it, and the air mixes around the home, with roughly +/-2% difference in humidity between rooms.

What water for an evaporative humidifier? Tap water is best, because it is the cheapest and does not affect operation or pollution (it is just ordinary natural evaporation). Ultrasonic humidifiers are a different matter, of course – as I wrote, they must use chemically pure water. But you can pour any water into an evaporative humidifier, as long as it does not stink;).

💰 Which humidifier for home? Evaporative radiator humidifiers – the Optimiser’s favourite as the cheapest humidifier.

  1. Evaporative radiator humidifiers with evaporative pads, such as the popular Polish “Monsun”, which you can find on Allegro (a Polish online marketplace):

allegro.pl

If we keep topping up the water, then on the coldest (driest) days the humidifier helps maintain a satisfactory humidity of 30–35% on critically dry days, when without it humidity is well below 30%. Often humidity can be kept closer to 40% – on dry days a single humidifier can release as much as 0.5–0.7 litres of water a day into the air, which already gives measurable results by preventing humidity from dropping below 30%.

Advantages:

+ Cheap to buy, at PLN 20–30 (about €5–7) apiece – I recommend 1–2 humidifiers per radiator/room

+ Cheap to run – all you need is to replace the inexpensive evaporative pads once a month, though if you let the replacement slip, the pad may start to rot…

+ no noise whatsoever

+ you can use ordinary tap water in a radiator humidifier

Disadvantages:

– limited output, so it is best to fit even 2 per radiator

– They are effective only on radiators – if we turn the heating down or off, their output drops. However, humidity problems usually occur during the heating season, and most of all on freezing days.

– Aesthetics, if someone dislikes having one fitted on a radiator

– I sincerely recommend paying extra and buying a mechanical evaporative humidifier;)

Ceramic evaporative radiator humidifiers – drawbacks and downsides:

– They are purely decorative, as they do not effectively release moisture into the surroundings because of their minimal evaporation surface

Ceramic radiator humidifiers do not release moisture effectively because of their minimal evaporation surface. Generally, such humidifiers are a joke;)
Ceramic humidifiers for radiators do not release moisture effectively because of their minimal evaporation surface. Generally, such humidifiers are a joke;)

The summary and a concrete answer on which humidifier to choose are at the beginning – if you have any further questions, please leave a comment.
Stay healthy!

In the article: Humidity management in buildings (in Polish) I shared information about humidifying the air in public buildings…

💧 The air purifier with humidifier that I recommend

Philips PureProtect Water 3400 – purifies and humidifies in one. It is usually cheapest on Amazon, especially just before and at the start of the season: Amazon. Review: Air purifier with humidifier Philips PureProtect Water 3400.

The Amazon link is an affiliate link: if you buy through it, I will receive a small commission, and the price for you does not change.

Leave a Reply