buildings energy efficiency

All_posts

Gravity Ventilation Drawbacks: 3 Myths and the Real Cost

Air quality monitor showing 2302 ppm CO2 in a living room with gravity ventilation

Yes, drawbacks and downsides. I really don’t like one-sided articles, but this one is. Simply put: if we didn’t care about energy use, health and comfort, gravity ventilation (natural or passive stack ventilation) would have plenty of big advantages over mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (HRV). But we do care, more and more, about energy use, air pollution, comfort and health. And in that light, gravity ventilation in a house or a flat in a block is just plain archaic and inefficient. In practice it is also often bad for your health, and it limits your comfort and your productivity. Advantages? Maybe two or three, and in practice they turn out to be drawbacks too.

Gravity ventilation: why it fails. Six key points: it works only thanks to the temperature difference; with airtight windows it hardly works; it is archaic and energy-inefficient; it often harms health, comfort and productivity; its supposed advantages are drawbacks in practice; the alternative is mechanical ventilation with heat recovery.

Gravity ventilation works mainly because warm air rises up the chimney, and fresh air is drawn in to replace it through windows or vents (window vents or dedicated wall vents). And what if there is no clear temperature difference between the room and the outdoors, and the windows are airtight? I hope you can see the problem.

Cold in through the window, warm out through the chimney. Close the window, and the CO2 stays.

Below I go through the apparent advantages, which today are myths that need busting.

💸 Myth 1: gravity ventilation is cheap to build and cheap to run

All you need is a few ventilation ducts in the bathrooms, kitchen and so on, plus vents in the windows or walls. (In many houses there are no vents at all.) It needs no electricity for fans and the like. True, but only in the bull***t sense of “true”, because in operation we waste huge amounts of heat. During the heating season we simply throw warm air out with no heat recovery at all, 24/7. Imagine someone keeping a window ajar next to a radiator 24/7, with the warm air escaping. Looks a bit silly, doesn’t it? It’s the same with gravity ventilation, except we can’t see it, because the warm air leaves through the chimney on the roof and we don’t feel it. On top of that, a new building needs the chimneys built, which isn’t that cheap either. So whatever we save at the construction stage comes back in the running costs. And the heat going up the chimney is still not the biggest loss. The biggest loss is that with high CO2 you think worse and life in that house is worse.

🎲 Myth 2: gravity ventilation is reliable and always works, 24/7

True, but bull***t true, because it only sometimes works well enough. For most of the year it works badly or not at all. In summer, for example, it practically won’t work, because the house is cooler than outside, so there is no proper chimney draught. If you have air conditioning and want to keep the windows shut, you will suffocate in summer. The CO2 stays in that cooled air, your head works worse, and the air conditioner exchanges nothing, because all it does is cool. In mild weather, when it’s too cold to open the windows but the temperature is still above zero, the draught in the chimney may not be strong enough to ventilate the rooms properly. And it’s worth saying that in a closed room with tightly shut windows you will suffocate even during the heating season.

Air quality monitor showing 2302 ppm CO2 in a house with gravity ventilation, six people, over 220 m2
Carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration in a large house with gravity ventilation: 2302 ppm with six people in a house of over 220 m2.

🔥 Myth 3: gravity ventilation uses no energy

That’s actually not true, because we keep throwing warm air out into space. In summer it hardly works. So it does use energy while it “works”, just heat instead of electricity, and a lot of it. The second thing: since it runs 24/7, it’s really a drawback, because you can’t switch it off when nobody is home. We live more and more actively and are often away (work, school, holidays, trips). Then we don’t need to ventilate the house that intensively. Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery is usually controlled from a wall panel, a smartphone or a computer. You can set schedules or switch it off remotely. More and more often there are also CO2 sensors that automatically reduce the airflow when nobody is home or only one or two people are (low CO2 concentration).

🌬️ Clear drawbacks and the impact on health and comfort

I mostly covered this when going through the apparent advantages, but let me stress a few more problems with gravity ventilation, in a flat in a block, a detached house and so on.

In winter the draught is there. On a warm day it practically isn’t.

Comfort, and indirectly health too, is a multidimensional subject. Let’s boil it down to thermal comfort and three main air quality parameters, see how gravity ventilation affects them, and which of them heat recovery ventilation (HRV) mostly takes care of.

🌡️ Temperature, or thermal comfort

Gravity ventilation needs air flowing in through the window (window vents or a window left slightly open). So in winter we have to let cold outdoor air into the rooms to get enough fresh air. That is very uncomfortable when freezing air flows straight into the zone where we stay. And any break in heating makes the air and the room cool down quickly. That is, if we ventilate properly at all. This is exactly why we usually keep the windows tightly shut, and suffocate…

🫁 Carbon dioxide (and oxygen): CO2/O2, the measure of fresh air

CO2 concentration (a lack of fresh air) lowers concentration, makes you feel worse, and makes you more sensitive to smells (it simply stinks…), and so on. As we’ve seen, we often don’t get enough fresh air. In winter we shut the windows tight so the freezing air doesn’t blow on us, and in spring, summer and autumn gravity ventilation usually doesn’t provide enough airflow.

An example of CO2 measurements with gravity ventilation and a tightly closed window:

More about CO2 and the lack of fresh air: CO₂ at home and at work: sleep, concentration, ventilation – a compendium from practice. The three main air parameters are also covered in 3 main indoor air quality parameters.

💧 Humidity

Generally, humidity that is too low (below 30%) or too high (above roughly 70%) harms health and reduces comfort. Good ventilation prevents water vapour from condensing. If it condenses in winter, things are very bad! In winter the air is very dry, so with proper ventilation we should be humidifying the rooms. So when water vapour condenses in winter, air exchange must be truly dreadful. Outside winter, condensation also points to insufficient ventilation.

Some heat recovery units (with an enthalpy exchanger) also recover moisture from the air, if the humidity is too low.

🌫️ Pollution: PM1, PM2.5 and PM10 dust

Gravity ventilation has no filtration of outdoor air, and indoor pollutants (off-gassing from plastics, textiles and so on) accumulate. With heat recovery you can fit filters that stop most of the dust from outside.

Personally, given how dependent we are on Russian gas, and to limit climate change, I think heat recovery from ventilation should be mandatory.

I honestly can’t understand how people put tens, even hundreds of thousands of zlotys into furniture, finishing, TVs and appliances, and then suffocate in that house because they didn’t take care of proper ventilation. All because a dozen or so thousand zlotys for heat recovery seemed like too much, or from ignorance. They suffocate without even knowing it, because they have no way to measure it. After all, who has a carbon dioxide meter at home? Below I listed the ones I use myself, and they cost only a fraction of what people spend on their TVs. If that sounds like you, it’s time to snap out of this lethargy and permanent suffocation.

🔧 How to live with it when the chimney is already there

No, I haven’t changed my mind and I’m not going to start praising gravity ventilation. But I know that not everyone will tear their house down tomorrow and install a heat recovery unit. If the chimney is already there, you can squeeze a bit more out of it, and above all stop harming yourself. Here is what I see most often in practice.

1. Air has to get in, get through and get out

Supply in the rooms (window or wall vent), extract grilles in the kitchen, bathroom and toilet, and between them a path: a gap under the door or a grille in the door. Sounds trivial, and half the houses don’t have it. Taped over the vent because it “blows”? Congratulations, you just switched your ventilation off. The chimney can’t pull anything out of a room where nothing comes in.

Supply in the room, a gap under the door, extract in the kitchen and bathroom.

2. Grilles and the cooker hood

A grille hidden behind a cupboard is ventilation hidden behind a cupboard. What stays is CO2, not just the kitchen smell. A cooker hood is worse: don’t connect it to the gravity duct. Grease in the duct is the small problem, because a strong hood can reverse the draught. If the home has a boiler or gas water heater with an open combustion chamber, it can pull flue gases into the flat, and that is not a question of comfort any more, it’s carbon monoxide. Use a recirculating hood with a filter, or a separate duct, if the rules allow it.

3. Measure, don’t guess

Put a CO2 meter in the bedroom and in the living room. Your nose gets used to the air after a few minutes, a meter doesn’t. Around 1000 ppm is already poor, and above that your head clearly works worse. Then you open a vent, or a window for a short cross-ventilation. That helps when there is no draught, but in winter it doesn’t replace a permanently open vent. The meters I use myself are below. If you want a cheap one first, here is a review of a cheap, small and good CO2 monitor.

4. Winter

An adjustable vent (pressure-controlled or humidity-controlled) is better than a window left ajar next to the radiator all day. It closes itself a bit when it’s windy, and you don’t heat the outdoors with the window fully open. But don’t close it completely, because then you’re back to square one, which is CO2. If it feels dry in a frost, air is probably being exchanged, and you need to humidify, not seal things up.

5. Summer and gas appliances

When it’s warmer outside than inside, the draught drops, and can even reverse. Air conditioning won’t fix that, because it cools what is already in the room, CO2 included. What’s left is cross-ventilation with the windows open. Choose a bathroom fan so that it doesn’t pull flue gases from the boiler or gas water heater. A hybrid chimney cap (with a fan) helps when the draught is weak, and it should switch off when the chimney pulls on its own.

6. Clean it

Window vents get dirty fast, and the dirt you can see is the lesser problem. Grilles and chimney caps need cleaning, and furniture must not block the openings. You won’t stop PM2.5 dust anyway, because gravity ventilation simply has no filter.

7. When to stop tinkering

Vents open, grilles uncovered, and the meter still shows high readings? The chimney has lost, and buying another sofa won’t help. Time for heat recovery, or at least mechanical extract with proper supply air. Gravity ventilation can’t be switched off while you are away either, and sometimes the draught simply isn’t there exactly when people are home.

🛠️ The air quality meters I recommend

  • 📲 Inkbird IAM-T2 – CO₂, temperature and humidity, Bluetooth and an app, battery life of over a month. I also recommend its twin with a more readable display, the Inkbird IAM-T1: IAM-T2 on Amazon | IAM-T1 on Amazon. My full review: Inkbird IAM-T2.
  • 🏠 Tuya WiFi 8-in-1 – among others CO₂, PM2.5 dust, formaldehyde, TVOC, temperature and humidity. I use it myself, and it is good enough to recommend as an alternative to the Dienmern DM125: Amazon | AliExpress
  • 🏆 IQAir AirVisual Pro – the best of the best, and also the most expensive: Amazon

These links are affiliate links: if you buy through them I get a small commission, and the price for you stays the same.

This article is the English version of the Polish original on optymalizatorbudynku.pl.

Leave a Reply